Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
-
-
Bunnies by the BayLittle Floppy Nibble Bunny (Carrot)
$32.99The Little Floppy Nibble Bunny in Carrot Orange is irresistibly sweet, tender, and unbelievably soft - now floppier than ever for extra snuggles. T...
View full details -
Hachette Book GroupLittle People, BIG DREAMS: Treasury: 50 Stories of Brilliant Dreamers
$39.99Dive deeper into the world of Little People, BIG DREAMS with this beautifully packaged and highly giftable keepsake treasury featuring 50 dreamers ...
View full details -
ToysmithLittle Red Wheelbarrow
$49.99Picture your kid wheeling this sweet, sturdy metal machine around the yard like a boss. A full 32" long, with easy grip handles, a wide base and ru...
View full details -
-
-
-
HapeLock & Learn Playboard
$37.99Preschoolers develop problem solving abilities and build fine motor skills with an interactive playboard! Kiddos learn how to open and close differ...
View full details -
PlayMonsterLoopdedoo
$49.99The Loopdedoo® spinning loom makes it fun and easy to make friendship bracelets in just a few minutes. And we love that it allows you to design you...
View full details -
JC ToysLots to Love Babies 5" All Vinyl Dolls in Play House with Accessories
$44.99Adorable Gift Set featuring 3 cute 5" Lots to Love Babies. Dolls are all vinyl and bath friendly. Each room of the the reusable playhouse features ...
View full details -
RavensburgerLotti Karotti Unicorn Puzzle (Action game)
$27.99Race your unicorns up Rainbow Hill in this magical twist on the classic Lotti Karotti game! Easy to learn and full of surprise moments, Lotti Karot...
View full details -
-
Manhattan ToyLove, Stella: My First Doll & Bassinet
$34.99Encourage nurturing role play with this gorgeous peach soft doll and bassinet set. Early learners practice key social and emotional skills as they ...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO - Black
$27.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO - Black & White Checkered
$27.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
-
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO - Limpet
$27.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO - Sherbert Confetti
$27.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO - Tongue Tied
$27.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO MagSafe - Black
$42.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO MagSafe - Clear Confetti Glitter
$42.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO MagSafe - Lavender Glow
$42.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO MagSafe - Navy
$42.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details -
LoveHandleLoveHandle PRO MagSafe - Sweet Gingham
$42.99Two-Way Kickstand The LoveHandle PRO has a sturdy kickstand that can be used in a horizontal or vertical orientation for a comfortable view no matt...
View full details
