Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Encourage active outdoor play with a high quality 10.25" synthetic leather football. Its textured surface is easy to catch and throw, and it's a gr...
View full details
Clever tweens proudly build their own money safe and use it to stash their treasures! Perfect for kids who like science kits and knowing how things...
View full details
Kiki's got the looks, the long-haired coat, and zero interest in shedding on your couch! Designer plush materials in cream and white with a lo...
View full details
Introducing Great Pretenders' swashbuckling Kira the Pirate Girl dress, the ultimate treasure for your adventurous little buccaneer! Prepare to set...
View full details
For all those “I want to be like you” moments and extravagant pretend play adventures, say hello to safe and natural pretend play makeup! Klee Natu...
View full details
For all those “I want to be like you” moments and extravagant pretend play adventures, say hello to safe and natural pretend play makeup! Klee Natu...
View full details
This all-in-one face painting kit turns Halloween, birthdays, and dress-up days into a magical art activity. Includes a rainbow of paints, a high-q...
View full details
Meet Scorch, a big, bold, striped sock puppet with a squeaky tongue and personality that's simply too big for one sock (he's tried to fit in smalle...
View full details
Bright colors, contrasting fur, and a set of signature chunky buttons, Buttons struts into the Sockette lineup with a look that's all his own (and ...
View full details
Glasses, a stripy tie, and antennae, Dylan struts into the Sockette lineup as one of the most instantly recognizable characters around (he insists ...
View full details
Rainbow-striped body, pink glasses, purple hair, Gloria doesn't blend in with anything, and that's exactly the point! Hand-knitted glove-style soc...
View full details
You'll never be bored when Konner comes out to play, this lively Tri-Color Welsh Corgi loves running circles around the yard just as much as he lov...
View full details
Looking for a unique addition to your fairytale stables? After hours of make believe in fantasy worlds, cuddle up with Kylie the Rainbow Unicorn. H...
View full details
"It looks so real" are the first words a child says when they meet their new La Baby doll. 16-inch soft body baby doll with a detailed vinyl head, ...
View full details
"It looks so real" are the first words a child says when they meet their new La Baby doll. 16-inch soft body doll with life-like brown eyes, plump ...
View full details
Young scientists love this hands-on opportunity to explore the fascinating life cycle of the Pink Spotted Ladybug! Over the course of 2 weeks, fami...
View full details
Hot pink, turquoise, and lime green make this bird puppet a genuine, jaw-dropping showpiece (subtlety was never on the design brief)! Full working...
View full details
Squawk! This grand crow puppet calls out with a real air-filled voice, no batteries needed, just pure puppet magic (and one very committed squawk)....
View full details
Vibrant orange, yellow, and green make this chameleon puppet absolutely impossible to miss on a shelf (blending in was never really the plan)! Pri...
View full details
Chomp! Meet the shark puppet that turns bath time, story time, or an ordinary Tuesday into full-blown Shark Week, no ocean required. Printed fabri...
View full details
A big printed-fabric octopus puppet from our Large Creatures line, eight arms of pure puppet drama! Printed fabric with excellent detail Part of t...
View full details
Any dragon fan is going to lose it over this one! Full working mouth, seriously fierce detail, built for real fire-breathing performances (fire not...
View full details
