Skip to content

About Us

Since 1976, Fantasy Island Toys has been a family-owned business in Downtown Fairhope, Alabama. It was originally founded by Jeane Byrd, with the aim of offering magical experiences to all who visit. The store was then passed down to sisters, Ginger Milligan and Kathie Byrd. Ginger, who is now the Vice President of The Good Toy Group, grew the store to be what we know it as today. In 2022, the store was passed to another set of sisters, Amanda Calhoun and Stevi Bell. Both of which feel incredibly passionate about maintaining this community landmark and who believe in Jeane’s mission of offering unmatched retail experiences to all. 

“For generations, we have been one of the South’s most beloved neighborhood toy stores thanks to the continued support of our customers and our community. We take pride in hand-selecting each toy to provide the best quality of play for our customers and to help children grow into the best versions of themselves. Reach out to our Toy Experts in-person or online to find  your perfect, unique toy,” Amanda Calhoun & Stevi Bell.