Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Your little farmer will have a blast with this fun farm tractor! The Fun Time Tractor comes with a farmer and five animals that all make realistic ...
View full details
Gaga Gorilla is a snuggly, cuddly, and soft plushie companion, blissfully lush, loppy, floppy, and squishy, and ready for millions of hugs and memo...
View full details
Sixty thousand puzzles and counting: Genius Square turns a simple dice roll into an endlessly replayable race to fill the grid. 60,000+ puzzles acr...
View full details
Ghost Bob has one favorite haunt: the dance floor. 7.5" x 4.7" x 5.1" size, with a 7" sitting height, made from soft polyester with polyester fiber...
View full details
Why did the 24" rubber chicken cross the road? To get to your house! Kids and adults squawk for joy when they discover that this giant, sparkly gag...
View full details
Warmies® Large 13” Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. These adorable soft toys are scented with real dri...
View full details
Goldie practically oozes with charm, one look into those amber eyes and puppy love is unavoidable! Gently weighted, floppy body with a lifelike ex...
View full details
Warmies® Large 13” Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. These adorable soft toys are scented with real dri...
View full details
This 59-piece starter set immerses young builders in the world of dinosaurs. 59-piece set with dinosaur figures like the T-Rex and the Sauropod, ma...
View full details
This ocean-themed GraviTrax Junior set brings a child-friendly introduction to marble track building. GraviTrax Junior track system with pieces siz...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable, offering hours of soothing warmth and comfort in this cheerful Gray Penguin design. Scented with real dried ...
View full details
Make their dreams of being a fairy come true with this whimsical dress up set that makes everything more magical: dancing, birthday parties, Hallow...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable, offering hours of soothing warmth and comfort in this friendly Green Long Neck Dinosaur design. Scented with...
View full details
This 10-piece building block set pairs wood construction with soft silicone edges for a safe, quiet build. Wooden blocks with silicone edges, plus...
View full details
The 90s called: Groovy Girls are back and are ready for the next generation of memory making through pretend play! In the colorful and inspiring w...
View full details
The 90s called: Groovy Girls are back and are ready for the next generation of memory making through pretend play! In the colorful and inspiring w...
View full details
The 90s called: Groovy Girls are back and are ready for the next generation of memory making through pretend play! In the colorful and inspiring w...
View full details
The 90s called: Groovy Girls are back and are ready for the next generation of memory making through pretend play! In the colorful and inspiring w...
View full details
Celebrate birthdays and any other occasion with Kai! Our classic teddy bear is here dressed to impress with irresistibly soft white and rainbow con...
View full details
Bring the magic of friendship anywhere with Gerald the elephant: a 13.5" plush version of the beloved character from Mo Willems' Elephant & Pig...
View full details
Bring the magic of friendship anywhere with Piggie: a 13.5" plush version of the beloved character from Mo Willems' Elephant & Piggie book seri...
View full details
Yes we know he's cute, but Don't Let The Pigeon Ride the Bus! Bring home a 13.5" plush version of The Pigeon, the persistent star of Mo Willems' be...
View full details
