Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
OK so a lava lamp is cool... but a jellyfish mood light that's also a bluetooth speaker is even cooler! This 10" lamp creates the perfect soothing ...
View full details
An educational playroom classic reimagined in soft silicone! Babies and toddlers discover shapes and develop fine motor skills as they sort each pi...
View full details
You might say that crafting a toy that’s both a blankie and a stuffed animal is a tall order, but we’ve combined both in Jetty, this plush shar...
View full details
Set the secret code, stash your treasures, and sleep well knowing they're secure! Siblings learn to respect others' privacy with this cute pink saf...
View full details
Polka dots and stripes bring a playful appearance to our lovable Gray Elephant Sshlumpie plush toy. Part stuffed animal, part blankie, this lightwe...
View full details
Young farm fans build fine motor skills while using a realistic working drill to screw tractor scenes together! The big, chunky pieces are safe for...
View full details
Load up hours of pretend play with a John Deere Lawn Tractor! Perfect for the kid who is obsessed with gardening and landscaping vehicles, this 1:1...
View full details
The fluffy form of the Persian breed has been captured in Juliette, Douglas' cuddly Cat stuffed animal! Decadently soft lilac gray plush materials ...
View full details
On the prowl for an exciting puzzle experience? Hunt no further! Our "Jungle Tiger" Wooden puzzle delivers hours of satisfying fun!Embark on a jour...
View full details
Play ball with a T-Ball starter set that helps future sluggers grow from beginner to pro! Kiddos gain confidence and grow their baseball skills as ...
View full details
One of MindWare’s most exciting products has been redesigned! KaBlocks Blast is an exciting version of MindWare’s best-selling KaBlocks constructio...
View full details
Shell-ebrate newborns with Kai Turtle Sshlumpie, a soft 18" sea turtle that's sure to become baby's new best friend. Sshlumpies are designed in a f...
View full details
The aliens are coming! Quick, use your foam ball blasters and defend the household! This fun new target blasting game gets kiddos moving and giggli...
View full details
Load up hours of imaginative adventures with this double-decker car transporter! A chunky design with intuitive buttons makes it easy for toddlers ...
View full details
Soothe baby into a peaceful sleep with a calming crib companion designed for the earliest stages of life. This versatile toy can be securely mounte...
View full details
Get ready for hands-on building fun! Kids build and take apart four different construction vehicles with the Kidoozie Tool Time Truck Set - perfect...
View full details
Encourage active outdoor play with a high quality 10.25" synthetic leather football. Its textured surface is easy to catch and throw, and it's a gr...
View full details
Introducing the first-ever DIY Banner by Numbers - a large-scale paint by numbers banner made specifically for parties and celebrations. Each bann...
View full details
Clever tweens proudly build their own money safe and use it to stash their treasures! Perfect for kids who like science kits and knowing how things...
View full details
Kitchen Play Set includes a double-door, three-drawer refrigerator, stove unit, and sink unit. Includes cooking utensils, ingredients, and other sm...
View full details
Add extra fun to Halloween costumes, birthday parties, sports games, and everyday dress up with face painting! KLUTZ makes it easy with this all-in...
View full details
Every LEGO fan's dream. Build, create, and race your own cars. Use the included 64-page book of step-by-step instructions to build one of 10 differ...
View full details
"It Looks So Real" These four words are exactly the first things a child exclaims once they see their new La Baby Doll Our 16" La Baby has a uniqu...
View full details
