Under $25

Monsters don't have to be scary. Toysmith's Monster Finger Puppets come in assorted styles taking on varying monster shapes and fit on a human fing...

Oh, what Monty the plush Mouse would give for a piece of fresh cheese! From Gouda to Brie, this endearing critter loves all kinds of cheeses! Monty...

Hop into cuteness with this delightful Natural Colors Mini Bunny Assortment! Each tiny bunny features charming earth-tone hues that bring warmth an...

Add some whimsy to your plush collection with a fantastic folklore friend who has emerged from the depths of Loch Ness: Nebbie the Sea Monster! Wit...

Move over Moo Deng – Nibbles the pygmy hippo is here! A charming and cuddly tribute to one of the animal kingdom's most endearing yet lesser-known ...

Oliver the plush Possum doesn't move all that quickly but that doesn't mean you shouldn't slow down and take the time to get to know him! This cudd...

A gift from the sky, Rae is comforting ray of sunshine.

Add magic to your day with Sorbet Unicorn plush from Palm Pals! Pastel hues, sparkled horn. A plush unicorn to sprinkle sparkle. Shop now!

Bring softness and sweetness to Baby’s teething journey with Parsnip the Pink Bunny Teether! This cuddly bunny’s pastel pink hues and soft, plush b...

This pigeon is clever, confident, and always up for adventure! His gray-and-white plush feathers and bright little eyes give him a quirky vibe you'...

Douglas' plush Pizza Rat Macaroon is the undisputed ruler of the city's underground train system! Sitting up proudly, this diminutive rodent muster...

This popular rainforest creature has been reimagined as a plump and lovable plush friend! A heavy dose of whimsy and pastel pink fur boasting unbel...

Some people call Poofy the plush Shih-Tzu a princess but she's more than just a cute face with a pink ribbon! Her lively personality and outgoing n...

Pookie the Mini Soft Pomsky is the perfect blend of fluffiness and charm, capturing the adorable features of this beloved hybrid breed in a tiny, c...

"Soft" doesn't even begin to describe this cuddly friend. Roarie is a 10" triceratops with deluxe plush fur in green and blue hues, expressive brow...

Rosie the Rosy Maple Moth is a delightful burst of color and fluffiness, inspired by one of nature’s most charming little critters! With her signat...

Loud colors, softer than expected! Rowdie is bold, spirited, and full of confident energy. His incredibly soft fabric contrasts perfectly with his...

Woah-oh, it's magic - Salem the black cat is good luck all year round! Whether you need Halloween decor, a familiar for your child's witch costume,...

 Meet Salty The Shrimp—your new cuddly sidekick with the sweetest little personality. Soft, snuggly, and full of charm, he’s ready for playtime, be...

Our classic Sock Monkey makes a wonderful gift. He is very soft and huggable and made of traditional sock knit material. Complete with a red pompom...

Boasting a whimsical design and bright colors, Sherbet the Seahorse stuffed animal exudes all the warmth of a sunny, summer's day! Douglas' playful...

Brimming with a hefty dose of cuteness, Shiloh is a fleecy plush Lamb that will win your heart in an instant! Perfectly pick up-able, Shiloh’s smal...

As snuggly as she is adorable, Shirlie the Soft Doodle Dog stuffed animal is an armful of puppy love! Lose yourself in the softness of this brown-e...

Slow down and smell the roses! This snail is peaceful, imaginative, and happiest moving at her own pace. A soft plush body paired with a swirled s...