Under $25

Monsters don't have to be scary. Toysmith's Monster Finger Puppets come in assorted styles taking on varying monster shapes and fit on a human fing...

A gift from the sky, Rae is comforting ray of sunshine.

Slugger Baseball from Palm Pals, an all-star baseball plush is ready to bring a home-run feeling to your life. Join in with #palmpalsparty.

Because of Percy the Porcupine's appearance, many people say he has a prickly personality, but we can assure you that is not the case! Percy's "qui...

Introducing our newest hyperfixation: Mantis Shrimp. They can punch at a speed of 60mph! They range in size from under an inch to over a foot long!...

10.5" REGAL EAGLE is a stuffed eagle who takes his role as a symbol of freedom. With soft black "feathers," soft white fur on his head, and amazing...

"Soft" doesn't even begin to describe this cuddly friend. Roarie is a 10" triceratops with deluxe plush fur in green and blue hues, expressive brow...

Woah-oh, it's magic - Salem the black cat is good luck all year round! Whether you need Halloween decor, a familiar for your child's witch costume,...

Gently resting amidst the corals of a colorful reef, Nina the plush Seahorse looks out on her magical undersea world. With all her playful fish fri...

Boasting a whimsical design and bright colors, Sherbet the Seahorse stuffed animal exudes all the warmth of a sunny, summer's day! Douglas' playful...

With floppy puppy paws and an irresistible expression, Shirlie the Mini Doodle Dog stuffed animal is a cuddly canine friend! Her tri-colored coat o...

Spankie our Yellow Lab stuffed animal is all of the fun of a puppy without any of the messes! Featuring a playful pose crafted with the highest qua...

4 rainbow brushes with sprinklesPowder, blending, crease and eyebrow brush3 1/2" w x 7 1/2" h x 1 1/2" d

18" Splash Sperm Whale is a perfect combination of softness for cuddles and realism for play! An open mouth with teeth and even a tuft of "water" c...

Sylvia, our Chocolate Lab stuffed animal is more than just a cute face, she's got a heart of gold and is as loyal as they come! And with her dense,...

Taddie the Tadpole plush toy is just the cutest! Made with fluffy, ultra-soft materials, this plush is perfect for cheering you up with a little hu...

Pickle Ball Pup is ready to play! Pickle Ball Pup may be cute as a button, but she’s also the best around and can beat anyone at her favorite sport...

Tucker is a cuddly Chocolate Lab stuffed animal whose love for food is nearly as great as his love for people! He's happy to sit, stay, lie down, o...

Surprise! Each of these water wigglers flips inside out to reveal a different character. Their super soft plush exterior makes them an ideal sensor...

VINNIE BANANA SLUG MACAROON

Indulge your senses every time you take Winnie, Douglas' luxurious Soft Cat stuffed animal into your arms! Her pale colored plush fur is cloud soft...

Bring home some magic with our beautifully crafted Wizard the Snowy Owl stuffed animal! Soft, white plush materials have been selected for our life...

Turn teething troubles into tail-wagging joy with Zeke the Puppy Teether! This playful pup, with his soft plush body and endearing floppy ears, is ...