Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Inspire purposeful imaginative play and open-ended storytelling with the Melissa & Doug Cheery Lane House Play Set! This new modular dollhouse ...
View full details
This plush spa wrap in a cherry print is perfect for lounging after a bath or during an at-home spa day. Plush, cherry-print fabric How to wear: wr...
View full details
1:20 scale, replica Chevrolet Silverado comes complete with a gooseneck connector and bumper hitch to fit with our full line of farm, ranch, and ou...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
Cuddle up to this adorable Chocolate Lab plush while waiting for Santa, or after long days of skiing, skating, or running around. This super soft p...
View full details
Get in the holiday spirit and enjoy meditative chill time with this gorgeously designed 1000-piece puzzle. It depicts a yuletide dream scene of fes...
View full details
The Souza Chuck Cowboy Suit is perfect costume for little wranglers with a big imagination and a wild spirit! Whether they’re riding across the ope...
View full details
Chunka Dunkas Kitty is covered in ultra-luxurious, butter soft, smoky gray and creamy white plush that feels like hugging a marshmallow. 12" tall a...
View full details
Welcome to the city, where storytelling adventures await on every corner! Encourage open-ended building with this gorgeous set of 36 wooden blocks:...
View full details
Transport kids to a world of imaginative play with the LEGO City Passenger Jet, an easy to build airplane toy for ages 4+. Kids can open the fusela...
View full details
Bump, slide, and switch your way to sweet, sweet revenge: Classic Sorry brings back the beloved racing game that's been delighting players for deca...
View full details
Left foot, yellow! Classic Twister turns simple instructions into a wonderfully wacky tangle of arms, legs, and giggles. Vinyl Twister mat and full...
View full details
Unzip and reach inside this oversized plush Claussen Kosher Dill Pickles jar to discover 3 pickle spears! Each has a unique playful embroidered exp...
View full details
Inspire creative confidence, foster STEAM learning and discover the power of play with Clixo! Discover a modern magnetic building experience that k...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable, offering hours of soothing warmth and comfort in this cheerful Clown Fish design. Scented with real dried Fr...
View full details
Be on the lookout for this big, bad shell! It's the Super Mario Bowser Shell plush from Club Mocchi- Mocchi-! Designed in Japan, Mocchi- Mocchi- ar...
View full details
The suspects you know, in the mansion you remember, with the weapons you love: this is Classic Clue, through and through. Gameboard, 6 suspect toke...
View full details
This chameleon-shaped sorter turns matching shapes and colors into a playful challenge. Chameleon-shaped sorter with multiple slots for matching co...
View full details
Construct A Truck 2.0 – Excavator. Upgrade Your Construction Project With A Remote Control! Take apart & put back together RC toy truck… Build ...
View full details
Construct A Truck 2.0 – Front Loader. Upgrade Your Construction Project With A Remote Control! Take apart & put back together RC toy truck… Bui...
View full details
This soft-bodied baby doll is designed for young children to cuddle and care for. Perfectly sized for small hands, encouraging nurturing play and e...
View full details
Bébé Calin Charming Pastel is a cuddly, lightweight 12-inch baby doll designed to be loved by little ones. Soft beanbag body that poses like a real...
View full details
Help your child develop their social and emotional skills with baby doll caretaking! This 12-inch baby doll is perfectly sized to be cradled in a y...
View full details
