Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Imaginations soar in the pretend play world of Calico Critters. Get started or expand your collection with a family of four soft, poseable Biscuit ...
View full details
Meet the Chocolate Rabbit family, dressed for their Thanksgiving best. Four soft, poseable white rabbits with brown-tipped ears in removable clothi...
View full details
Meet the Citrus birds, a vibrant pair ready to join your Calico Critters village. Two soft, poseable songbirds in vibrant yellow and light blue, dr...
View full details
Meet the Cottontail Rabbit family, dressed in their best bows, hats, and vests. Four soft, poseable gray and white rabbits in removable clothing: f...
View full details
Meet the Dalmatian family, dressed in their classic black-and-white spotted best. Family of four soft, poseable Dalmatian dogs, with two parents an...
View full details
This whimsical playset brings a parade of imaginative Calico Critters fun to any collection. Playset designed to spark storytelling adventures alon...
View full details
Enter the magical world of fairy babies with Mushroom Fairy's adorable fungi home. Filled with storytelling accessories including a tiny mushroom f...
View full details
Babies love to ride the Floating Cloud Rainbow Train at the Amusement Park. Pastel-colored train with rotating wheels that move forwards and backwa...
View full details
Meet the Koala family, ready to move into your Calico Critters village. Soft, poseable koala figures dressed in removable clothing How to play: dre...
View full details
Meet the Latte Cat family, dressed in their holiday best and ready for a family outing. Four soft, flocked, poseable cats in removable clothing: pa...
View full details
Meet the Sea Otter family, dressed for seaside storytelling adventures. Family of four soft, poseable Sea Otters in removable striped outfits with ...
View full details
Imaginations soar in the pretend play world of Calico Critters. Get started or expand your collection with a family of four soft, poseable Snow Leo...
View full details
Meet the Toy Poodle family, a lively bunch ready to move into your Calico Critters village. Father Frank teaches soccer on weekends, mother Veronic...
View full details
This pink ice cream van serves up delicious pretend treats at the Amusement Park. Rotating wheels and steering wheel, seating up to 4 figures in "d...
View full details
Welcome to Candy Cane Manor—a magical holiday home full of sparkle, surprises, and sweet holiday fun! Inside this festive advent calendar, your lit...
View full details
Maui, the demigod of the wind and sea, is ready for adventure in this Moana-inspired fashion doll. Removable skirt with four accessories including ...
View full details
Pounce into cozy adventures with our Black Cat Cuddle Cape. A playful and snuggly accessory perfect for little ones who love a touch of magic! Craf...
View full details
Load up hours of pretend play with a CAT skid steer loader! Perfect for the kid who is obsessed with construction and landscaping vehicles, this 1:...
View full details
A working wind-up reel and 10 numbered magnetic fish turn casual play into real counting and matching practice. Wooden magnetic fishing game with 2...
View full details
Welcome to the adventures of Chance and Patches! Chance the Boxer loves to explore the world with his BFF Patches the Calico Cat (sold separately)....
View full details
Charlize is a glamorous little piggy who's pretty in pink, and she wears the color so well you'd expect her on a fashion runway. Luxury plush fur i...
View full detailsThis Charm Changers set lets her build a techno-girl look, one interchangeable charm at a time. Interchangeable charm-style design How to wear: sna...
View full details
Inspire happiness for tweens and teens with an adjustable pink and white crossbody bag with a bow design! At a perfect 10.8" x 8.46" x 3.9" size wi...
View full detailsThis beginner-friendly needlepoint kit lets kids stitch their own checkered zippered pouch, no framing or finishing required. Includes a pre-sewn c...
View full details
