Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
A natural-born optimist, Amuseables Siofra Shamrock, can find the silver lining in any situation. Her glass isn’t half full; it’s positively overfl...
View full details
There is nothing sour about Amuseables Sourdough! This lovable loaf is baked to perfection in textured beige and brown fur. With a big, stitched sm...
View full details
Flappy the Elephant is an adorable singing animated plush with two different play modes. Press the left foot to play an interactive game of peek-a-...
View full details
Looking for a unique addition to your fairytale stables? After hours of make believe in fantasy worlds, cuddle up with Anita the Rainbow Unicorn. H...
View full details
This is the most realistic Ant Habitat ever! The fascinating Inside/Outside cutaway design allows you to watch ants dig, excavate, forage, and prob...
View full details
Jasmine's magical adventures begin with this gorgeous, premium quality 3-piece pant set in vibrant turquoise tones and contrasted with fancy golden...
View full details
Challenge your friend, your sibling or even your parent to a 60 second shootout! You both have 1 minute to score as many points as possible to win....
View full details
Arnold the plush Schnauzer puppy is full of mischief and spunk! Bright, amber colored eyes lend him a sparkle of lifelike charm and reveal Douglas'...
View full details
Asher the Dragon Sshlumpie will spark your baby's imagination with magic and adventure! His cheerful face, soft green plush, and tiny wings make hi...
View full details
A lovable soul, August the Golden Retriever stuffed animal can be counted on whenever you need a gentle friend at your side! Fantastically soft mat...
View full details
From bibs to booties to baby bear. Over 30 baby doll essentials come packaged in this 9.5in x 7in x 4in zippered case. 3yr plus
Snug in her cozy cocoon, a dreamy Baby doll waits to see what imaginative adventures the day will bring! Douglas' Baby Butterfly Hug has been desig...
View full details
There's a special place in everyone's hearts for their first teddy bear, so get the new mother or baby in your life a cuddly bear that will stand t...
View full details
There's a special place in everyone's hearts for their first teddy bear, so get the new mother or baby in your life a cuddly bear that will stand t...
View full details
Baby shark, doo doo doo doo doo doo! This soft baby doll plush is a fin-tastic gift for summer newborns. An innovative spin on soft dolls, this snu...
View full details
A toddler’s first music box; wind it up and watch the owl and teddy bear spin and turn to a pleasant and relaxing tune. Beautifully decorated, it i...
View full details
Barbie Cutie Reveal Cuddly Series dolls offer the cutest wow moments as kids open the package to find 10 surprises! Which doll will you reveal? The...
View full details
Bashful Silver Bunny just loves cuddles to keep warm during the winter nights. Snuggly soft in silver fur, this bunny has long loppy ears, and the ...
View full details
Fashionable kiddos make a statement as they arrive in style carrying a trendy beach tote! Measuring an impressive 11" x 5" x 9", this tote is perfe...
View full details
Bébé Bath Alyzéé loves to splash in the water! This 12-inch play companion is so light, it floats! There is a tab sewn onto the doll's back so it c...
View full details
Bebe Calin Maria is the ideal first baby doll for the little ones ages 18 months and up. This adorable 12-inch baby doll is just the right size to ...
View full details
Bébé Calin Unicorn is a 12-inch baby doll that is perfectly sized to be cradled in a young child's arms and is ideal for hugging and cuddling. The ...
View full details
