Free Shipping on Orders $100+

Get Directions Call Us Birthday Buckets Gift Finder Wishlist

Get Directions
Call Us
Birthday Buckets
Gift Finder
Wishlist

Menu

View cart

View account

New & Popular
- New
  
  Local
  
  Gift Boxes
- Trending
  
  Fidget Toys
  
  Putty & Slime
  
  Best Sellers
  
  Nostalgic Toys
  
  Candy
- Top Brands
  
  Jellycat
  
  Douglas
  
  Smart Toys & Games
  
  Hape
  
  Calico Critters
  
  Tonies
  
  Brio
  
  Iscream
  
  Carma Games
  
  Manhattan Toys
  
  Melissa & Doug
- Apparel
  
  Shorts
  
  Jewelry
  
  Makeup
- Seasonal
  
  Summer
  
  Halloween
  
  Christmas
  
  Easter
Arts & Crafts
- Activity Books
- Supplies
- Kits
- Stickers
- Pens
Active Play
- Outdoor
  
  Water Play
  
  Bubbles
  
  Kites
- Sports
  
  Balls & Discs
  
  Baseball/Softball
  
  Racquet
- Ride On's
  
  Indoor
  
  Scooters
- Science & Exploration
  
  Science
  
  Nature
  
  Robots
  
  Electronics
  
  Space
Games & Puzzles
- Books
  - Learning
  - Sticker
  - Local
  - Activity
  - Picture
- Games
- Puzzles
  - Jigsaw
Imaginative Play
Lego & Construction
- Magnetic
  
  Magna-Tiles
  
  SMARTMAX
- Lego
  
  Classic
  
  City
  
  Friends
  
  Harry Potter
- Blocks
Books, Music & More
- Books
  - Picture
  - Story
  - Learning
  - Fiction
  - Local Author
- Music
- Tonies
- Electronics

Log in

Close

New & Popular
- New
  - Local
  - Gift Boxes
- Trending
- Top Brands
  - Jellycat
  - Douglas
  - Smart Toys & Games
  - Hape
  - Calico Critters
  - Tonies
  - Brio
  - Iscream
  - Carma Games
  - Manhattan Toys
  - Melissa & Doug
- Apparel
  - Shorts
  - Jewelry
  - Makeup
- Seasonal
  - Summer
  - Halloween
  - Christmas
  - Easter
Arts & Crafts
- Activity Books
- Supplies
- Kits
- Stickers
- Pens
Active Play
- Outdoor
  - Water Play
  - Bubbles
  - Kites
- Sports
- Ride On's
  - Indoor
  - Scooters
- Science & Exploration
  - Science
  - Nature
  - Robots
  - Electronics
  - Space
Games & Puzzles
- Books
  - Learning
  - Sticker
  - Local
  - Activity
  - Picture
- Games
- Puzzles
  - Jigsaw
Imaginative Play
Lego & Construction
- Magnetic
  - Magna-Tiles
  - SMARTMAX
- Lego
  - Classic
  - City
  - Friends
  - Harry Potter
- Blocks
Books, Music & More
- Books
  - Picture
  - Story
  - Learning
  - Fiction
  - Local Author
- Music
- Tonies
- Electronics

Skip to content

← Back Home

Plush

Sort by

Filters

age 3-4 years Remove filter

Filter

FILTERS

view all

Interest

Search

Age

Search

Gender

Search

Girls

Price

Search

Brand

Search

Collection

Plush

clear

10
1449
1518
15862
15863
16 dog toy
1626
1919
24 dog toy
2409
25-50
282
304461
304799
304805
3602
3604
4519
4536
4604
4666
4699
50-75
54401
54402
54403
6056144
6068708
90001
90002
Active Play
activity book
Activity Cube
Addie
African
age 0-1 years
age 1-2 years
age 10-11 years
age 11-12 years
age 12-13 years
age 13+ years
age 2-3 years
age 3-4 years
age 4-5 years
age 5-6 years
age 6-7 years
age 7-8 years
age 8-9 years
age 9-10 years
preschoolers-3-5
preteen
teen
ages 2+ yrs.
all ages
Amuseables
Amuseables Weather
anictpb12
anictpb3
Animal
Animal puppets
animal toy
animals
anirolls
anirollz
anxiety relief
apple of my eye
Asst12Pc
aurora-world-inc
Aussie
Australian
australian shepherd
avian
bababoo-and-friends
babies
Baby
baby activity books
baby activity toy
baby blue & yellow macaw
baby blue & yellow parrot
baby Blue and gold macaw
baby blue and yellow macaw
baby blue and yellow parrot
baby book
baby books
baby development
Baby Rattles
baby red macaw
baby red parrot
baby sensory
baby toys
baby toys - gifts
back to school
baskets
bear
Bears
Big Dogs
bird hand puppet
birds
Blaze
blue
Books
Border
brown bear
brown eyes
Bulldog
Bully Breeds
bumpas-products
Buttons
Camel
candy canes
capybarras
Carm
Cat
cats
Cats & Kittens
Cattle
cb41201
cb62363
cb62375
cb62598
Chameleon
Chap
character plush
Chase
chester black lab
chicks
Choc
Chocolate
christmas
christmas cap
cocoa chocolate lab
collectable
collectables
Collectibles
Collie
comforting
coosy-wslicensing
Corgi
cowboy frog
cows
cozy
Crane
Crowned
cuddle-barn
cuddles
cuddly
cuddly plush fur
cute
Dachshund
Dalmatian
Deer & Moose
design blocks
Developmental Toy
dexterity
dino
Dinosaur
dinosaur lover
dinosaurs
dinsosaurs
DLux
DLux Collection
dog
dog toy
doggies
dogs
Dogs & Puppies
dolls
Doodle
douglas company inc
douglas dog chester black lab
douglas dog cocoa chocolate lab
douglas dog honey golden retriever
Douglas Dogs
douglas-toys
Dragon
dt4607
ducks
Dunham
UPC
dynos
easter
Easter & Springtime
Easter And Spring
eco
embroidered features
expressive
fabrics
facial horns
Fantasy
Fantasy Friends
Farm
farrah pink fawn sshlumpie
Fashion
felines
Fine Motor Skills
first books
flat style
Flying
foods
Fox
friend
friends
frog
frogs
FUNdamental: Independent Play
FUNdamental: Motor Skills
fungus
fuzzy
Games
gardens
girls
General
German
giant
Giraffe
Gld
Gldn
glove puppets
goat
goats
Goats & Sheep
Golden Retrievers
goose
grasping
Gray
green
green bird
greens
Grm
gund
Handful
Hardy
Hedgehog
hello kitty
Hndfl
honey golden retriever
hooves
horns
Horses
house cats
Huddles
hues
huge
hugging
Huskies
Husky
imaginary adventures
inchworm
indonesia
infant
infants
dance
farm
trends
unicorn
Inu
irresistible
jellycat
Jingle Jingle
Jump
Jungle
Kash
kawaii
kid
kid safe dog toy
kid safe toy
king
Kitn
kitten
kittens
kitty
L
Lab
Labddl
Labradors
Lambs
language skills
Lawrence
learning colors
Lifelike
Lil'
Little Critters
lizard
lizards PC009713
Llama
machine washable
mary meyer
mary-meyer-stuffed-toys
master toys - novelties
master-toys-and-novelties
melissa-doug
micro plush
Miles
milkshake
Mini Softs
mint
Mouse
Movies & Videos
mushrooms
nany
Nia
novelty
Octopus & Squid
opossums
orientation
Other
over-100
oversize
Owl
parrot
parrots
pastels
Pauline
PC004802
PC004804
Percy
Petunia
Phoebe
Pig
pigs
Pink
pink fawn
pjm-distributions
plush
plush dog toy
plush fur
plush pal
plush toy
plushie
Polar Animals
pomeranians
Pomsky
Poofy
pool
Porcupine
possums
potatoes
Prehistoric
Pretend
pretend play
prince
pup
puppet
puppet company
Puppets & Plush
puppies
puppy
purple
Purses & Bags
QB15785
QB16059
QB16061
QB16095
QB16825
QB20231
QB20701
QB20705
QB20945
QB21833
QB22431
QB22779
QB22780
QB22782
QB22906
QB23892
QB25100
QB25101
QB25104
QB26520
QB27953
QB27977
QB30465
QB30470
QB30478
QB30485
QB30506
QB30622
QB30638
QB31909
QB32822
QB32826
QB33251
QB34343
QB34346
QB35933
QB36098
QB36099
QB36420
QB36422
QB36430
QB36436
QB36438
QB36441
QB36443
QB36444
QB36458
QB36615
QB36617
QB36622
QB36763
QB36792
QB37378
QB37379
QB37381
QB37382
QB37464
QB37465
QB38444
QB38445
QB38446
QB38449
QB38452
QB38453
QB39013
QB39015
QB39063
QB39065
QB39258
QB39903
QB40036
QB40042
QB40416
QB40417
QB40419
QB40423
QB40860
QB40877
QB40880
QB40883
QB40885
QB40886
QB40896
QB779
QuickBooks
rainbows
rattlers
red & gold macaw
red & yellow macaw
red and gold macaw
red and yellow macaw
red bird
Retriever
Rhea
roarie soft green dino
rodents
rolls
Rudy
Sanrio
santa cap
Sasquatch
Sassy Pet Saks
schylling
science
sea animals
Sea Life
Sea Turtles
Seals & Sea Otters
seasonal
self-soothing
sensory
sensory toys
shapes
Sharks & Rays
Shep
Shepherd
shepherds
Shiba
Shih-Tzu
shrimp
Skunk
Sloths
slugs
Sm
small bird puppet
small plush
Smokey
snails
Snowy
snuggles
snuggly
snuggly blanket
snugly
social development
social skills
soft
soft books
soft dog toy
soft spikes
softies
softs
south american
Spats
spin-master
Spotted
squeaky bird
squeaky birds
squidgy
Squirrel
squishy
faves
STN Pushed
STN Updated
strawberry
stress relief
striped hat
Striper
Strp
stuffed
stuffed animal
STUFFED ANIMALS
stuffed insect
stuffers
Stuffie
stuffies
SU23
Summertime Fun
sushi
sushi cat
Sweet Softies
Sylvia
T-Rex
tan
teal
teddy bear
Teddy Bears
teether
teethers
textures
tgtg-au-24
tgtg-au24-1919
tgtg-au24-304461
tgtg-au24-4536
tgtg-au24-cb62375
tgtg-fa23-1449
tgtg-fa23-dt4607
tgtg-ho23-1850
tgtg-ho23-2067
tgtg-ho23-281
tgtg-ho23-6532
tgtg-ho24-15862
tgtg-ho24-15863
tgtg-ho24-2409
tgtg-ho24-282
tgtg-ho24-304799
tgtg-ho24-304805
tgtg-ho24-3602
tgtg-ho24-3604
tgtg-ho24-4699
tgtg-ho24-54401
tgtg-ho24-54402
tgtg-ho24-54403
tgtg-ho24-6056144
tgtg-ho24-6068708
tgtg-ho24-90001
tgtg-ho24-90002
tgtg-ho24-cb41201
tgtg-ho24-cb62363
tgtg-ho24-cb62598
tgtg-holiday-24
tgtg-sp24-1518
tgtg-sp24-4604
tgtg-sp24-4666
tgtg-sp24-anictpb12
tgtg-spring-24
tgtg-su23-anictpb3
tgtg-su24-1626
tgtg-summer-24
tgtgau24all
tgtgau24babytoys-gifts
tgtgau24creaturefeature
tgtgau24cuddlycrawlers
tgtgau24earlylearningtoys
tgtgau24new-cool
tgtgau24paw-somepreschoolers
tgtgau24pg02-03
tgtgau24pg14-15
tgtgau24pg16-17
tgtgau24pg20-21
tgtgau24pg22-23
tgtgau24plush
tgtgau24theboocrew
tgtgau24tween-teen
tgtgau24yearbookdoodles
tgtgfa23all
tgtgfa23appleofmyeye
tgtgfa23babytoys-gifts
tgtgfa23backtoschool
tgtgfa23pg02
tgtgfa23pg10
tgtgfa23plush
tgtgHO19all
tgtgHO19BabyToys&Gifts
tgtgHO19ImaginativePlay
tgtgHO19Laugh&PLAY
tgtgHO19Pg24
tgtgHO19Plush
tgtgho23all
tgtgho24all
tgtgho24allthroughthehouse
tgtgho24babytoys-gifts
tgtgho24books
tgtgho24earlylearningtoys
tgtgho24gamezone
tgtgho24new-cool
tgtgho24pg02-03
tgtgho24pg12-13
tgtgho24pg14-15
tgtgho24pg20-21
tgtgho24pg22-23
tgtgho24pg24-25
tgtgho24pg28-29
tgtgho24pg32-33
tgtgho24pg34-35
tgtgho24playfromdayone
tgtgho24plush
tgtgho24purefun!
tgtgho24royaltales
tgtgho24sparkcreativity
tgtgho24starstruck
tgtgho24tween-teen
tgtgho24twinkletwinklelittlestars
tgtgho24wishingonastar
tgtgsp24activities
tgtgsp24all
tgtgsp24bunnypalooza
tgtgsp24featherweather
tgtgsp24mushroomlands
tgtgsp24new-cool
tgtgsp24pg04-05
tgtgsp24pg06-07
tgtgsp24pg10-11
tgtgsp24pg12-13
tgtgsp24plush
tgtgsu23all
tgtgsu23coolestdrops
tgtgsu23new-cool
tgtgsu23pg14
tgtgsu23plush
tgtgsu23tween-teen
tgtgsu24all
tgtgsu24marshfellowfriends
tgtgsu24pg14-15
tgtgsu24plush
Thatchr
the-puppet-company
toadstool and heart embellishment
triceratops
tropical bird
Tucker
Tutu
tyrannosaurus rex
under-25
underwater
unicorns
Unicorns & Fantasy Horses
vegetables
vietnam.
walking
weighted
weird
western
white cat
wild animal
wild animals
Wild Cats
Wildlife
Winston
winter
Winter Holidays
Wizard
wolf
wolves
Wolves & Foxes
worm
worm plush
Yellow
Zach
Zephyr

age 3-4 years Remove filter

There are no products matching your search

View all products

Previous
1
…
7
8

Sort by

Customer Service

Create Account
Wishlist
Birthday Buckets
My Orders
Contact Us
Shipping Policy
Refund Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

Shop

New & Popular
Arts & Crafts
Active Play
Games & Puzzles
Imaginative Play
Lego & Construction
Books, Music & More

Our Store

(251) 928-1720
335 Fairhope Ave, Fairhope, AL
hello@fantasyislandtoys.com
Giving Back
Visit the Store
About Us
Events
Blog

Sign up to get updates on new arrivals

Find us on Facebook Find us on Instagram Find us on Pinterest Find us on TikTok Find us on YouTube

Site by Capital Commerce

Added to your cart:

** total_quantity ** | ** unit_price ** / ** unit_measure **

Cart subtotal

View cart ()