$10 off of $50 with AUTUMN26 + Free shipping on orders $100+
Get Directions Call Us Birthday Buckets Gift Finder Gift Certificates
Skip to content
← Back Home

Novelty

Get ready for surprises, smiles, and a little bit of silliness with our Novelty Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! Packed with quirky, fun, and unexpected finds, this collection is all about playful moments that stand out from the ordinary.

From goofy gadgets and prank toys to light-up novelties, fun desk toys, party favorites, and unique impulse items, these playful picks are perfect for laughter, gifting, and lighthearted entertainment. Whether you’re looking for a stocking stuffer, a party favor, or just something fun and different, the Novelty Collection always delivers big personality in small packages.

Why customers love our Novelty Collection:
• Fun, quirky, and unexpected toy designs
• Perfect for party favors, gifts, and stocking stuffers
• Great impulse buys with instant entertainment value
• Light-up, silly, and interactive novelty items
• Always fresh, fun, and conversation-starting

At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe play should always have a sense of humor. Explore our Novelty Collection and discover the fun side of surprise!

Get ready for surprises, smiles, and a little bit of silliness with our Novelty Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! Packed with quirky, fun, and unexpected finds, this collection is all about playful moments that stand out from the ordinary.

From goofy gadgets and prank toys to light-up novelties, fun desk toys, party favorites, and unique impulse items, these playful picks are perfect for laughter, gifting, and lighthearted entertainment. Whether you’re looking for a stocking stuffer, a party favor, or just something fun and different, the Novelty Collection always delivers big personality in small packages.

Why customers love our Novelty Collection:
• Fun, quirky, and unexpected toy designs
• Perfect for party favors, gifts, and stocking stuffers
• Great impulse buys with instant entertainment value
• Light-up, silly, and interactive novelty items
• Always fresh, fun, and conversation-starting

At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe play should always have a sense of humor. Explore our Novelty Collection and discover the fun side of surprise!

  • Flower
    Flower
    UGears

    Flower

    $6.00

    Age: 6+ 24' magnetic pixio-blocks 4' colors This pixelated yet delicate flower can be turned into at least 10 different cute and intriguing charact...

    View full details
  • Toysmith

    Say Whaaat!

    $6.99

    Ka-BOOM! BEEP BEEP! and WOMP, WOMP! Say hello to the most outrageous, pint-sized powerhouses of sound: our Say Whaaaaat?! Air Horns, each under 4 i...

    View full details
  • Party Animal

    NFL SqueezyMates 2026

    $9.99

    Each blind pack contains one figure with a carabiner keychainFigure Size: 2.5" tallOfficially LicensedAges Each sold separately