Aerobie Pro Ring
For exhilarating flying disc games, nothing compares with the high performance of the Aerobie Pro Ring. This flying disc was used to set a world re...
View full detailsExplore everything we have to offer in one place with our All Inventory Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This is your go-to destination for browsing our full selection of toys, games, plush, STEM kits, crafts, collectibles, sensory favorites, and more—all in a single, easy-to-shop collection.
Whether you’re searching for the perfect gift, browsing for inspiration, or looking for something new and exciting, our full inventory brings together every category, brand, and play style we carry in-store and online.
Why customers love our All Inventory Collection:
• Complete selection of all toys and categories in one place
• Easy way to browse gifts, favorites, and new arrivals
• Includes STEM, plush, sensory, games, vehicles, and more
• Perfect for browsing, gifting, and discovering new items
• Always updated with our latest inventory
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe finding the perfect toy should be fun and simple. Explore our All Inventory Collection and discover everything waiting to be played with!
Explore everything we have to offer in one place with our All Inventory Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This is your go-to destination for browsing our full selection of toys, games, plush, STEM kits, crafts, collectibles, sensory favorites, and more—all in a single, easy-to-shop collection.
Whether you’re searching for the perfect gift, browsing for inspiration, or looking for something new and exciting, our full inventory brings together every category, brand, and play style we carry in-store and online.
Why customers love our All Inventory Collection:
• Complete selection of all toys and categories in one place
• Easy way to browse gifts, favorites, and new arrivals
• Includes STEM, plush, sensory, games, vehicles, and more
• Perfect for browsing, gifting, and discovering new items
• Always updated with our latest inventory
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe finding the perfect toy should be fun and simple. Explore our All Inventory Collection and discover everything waiting to be played with!
On Sale
For exhilarating flying disc games, nothing compares with the high performance of the Aerobie Pro Ring. This flying disc was used to set a world re...
View full details
On Sale
Flappy the Elephant sings, plays peekaboo, and flaps those big ears every step of the way. 12" animated singing plush elephant with two play modes:...
View full details
On Sale
Every baby deserves a best friend before they can even say the word, and this squishy little bear is ready to apply for the job. Baby GUND's My Fir...
View full details
On Sale
There is a particular kind of love reserved for a baby's very first teddy bear, the one that ends up softer than a cloud and somehow present in eve...
View full details
On Sale
Peeki has one trick and he is extremely committed to it: peek-a-boo, on demand, for as many rounds as Baby can handle. This animated plush pup sits...
View full details
On Sale
Keep little ones moving with Muttsy and Philbin! These ring rattles feature timeless design with GUND's Forever Friends classic characters, sportin...
View full details
On Sale
Kai Bear is a best-selling whimsical plush teddy in a modern design. 12" tall, with an extra-large head and ears, a faux suede nose, and soft fur f...
View full details
On Sale
Meet Philbin, a compact cuddle buddy with extra large paws and swirls of soft, tousled chocolate brown plush. 7" tall, sized for snuggles on the go...
View full details
On Sale
Muttsy Puppy has been a best-selling classic plush for over 30 years. 14" long, with signature soft swirly fur, long floppy ears, and faux suede pa...
View full details
On Sale
Ready, set, explore! Toothpick has a nose for adventure, wherever it may be. A slender silhouette with long limbs, soft curly fur, and playful, flo...
View full details
On Sale
Bring the magic of friendship anywhere with Gerald the elephant: a 13.5" plush version of the beloved character from Mo Willems' Elephant & Pig...
View full details
On Sale
Bring the magic of friendship anywhere with Piggie: a 13.5" plush version of the beloved character from Mo Willems' Elephant & Piggie book seri...
View full details
On Sale
Yes we know he's cute, but Don't Let The Pigeon Ride the Bus! Bring home a 13.5" plush version of The Pigeon, the persistent star of Mo Willems' be...
View full details
On Sale
Order up! This adorable 9.5" plush features Pusheen holding a blue bento box meal, filled with fluffy white rice and crispy shrimp tempura for a he...
View full details
On Sale
The super cute Hello Kitty arrives dressed as a Circus Acrobat in this huggable plush toy. Embroidered and satin details create her carnival perfor...
View full details
On Sale
Every day's an outdoorsy adventure with Hello Kitty and Friends! This series of 3.5" miniature plush toys features some of Sanrio`s most popular c...
View full details
On Sale
Have a sweet, snuggly coffee break with Hello Kitty and Friends! Hello Kitty arrives in an adorable white latte-inspired teddy bear outfit, complet...
View full details
On Sale
Release chaos with the HEX BOTS Alive Inside Explodapede! This remote control insect toy is guaranteed to get a scream out of anyone afraid of inse...
View full details
On Sale
Hey pranksters! Creep out friends and family with a hyper-realistic robot toy lizard that's guaranteed to get a scream out of anyone afraid of rept...
View full details
On Sale
Crawl on any terrain: Enjoy the creepy-crawly movement of this autonomous robot insect as it crawls across any room, floor, or outdoor space! The c...
View full details
On Sale
Kian is a cute, shaggy, and cuddly spaniel puppy that's ready to become any plush lover's best friend, from the GUND classic Animals collection. 10...
View full details
On Sale
4.5oz containers of Kinetic Sand to mix, mold, squish, cut & more. With a range of vibrant colors and white, brown & Kinetic Beach Sand, w...
View full details
On Sale
Turn the milestone of losing a tooth into a comforting moment with the Lost Tooth Toothpick Bear, your little one's favorite bedtime buddy. 7" size...
View full details