$50 to $75
Discover amazing gifts and exciting favorites in our $50–$75 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features premium toys, games, plush, STEM kits, collectibles, and creative playsets that deliver unforgettable fun and exceptional value.
Perfect for birthdays, holidays, special occasions, or “just because” surprises, these handpicked items offer something for every age and interest — from imaginative adventures and educational experiences to cozy companions and family game nights.
Why shoppers love our $50–$75 Collection:
• Great value for premium toys and gifts
• Perfect for birthdays and special occasions
• Exciting options for a variety of ages and interests
• Educational, creative, and interactive play
• Thoughtfully selected customer favorites
At Fantasy Island Toys, we make it easy to find meaningful gifts kids will love. Explore our $50–$75 Collection and discover standout toys that create lasting memories and endless fun!
Discover amazing gifts and exciting favorites in our $50–$75 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features premium toys, games, plush, STEM kits, collectibles, and creative playsets that deliver unforgettable fun and exceptional value.
Perfect for birthdays, holidays, special occasions, or “just because” surprises, these handpicked items offer something for every age and interest — from imaginative adventures and educational experiences to cozy companions and family game nights.
Why shoppers love our $50–$75 Collection:
• Great value for premium toys and gifts
• Perfect for birthdays and special occasions
• Exciting options for a variety of ages and interests
• Educational, creative, and interactive play
• Thoughtfully selected customer favorites
At Fantasy Island Toys, we make it easy to find meaningful gifts kids will love. Explore our $50–$75 Collection and discover standout toys that create lasting memories and endless fun!
-
-
On Sale
JellycatBartholomew Bear (Huge)
$64.99| /Tawny-tousled and full of softness, Bartholomew Bear is the perfect bedtime buddy. Read him a story, sing him 'The Teddy Bears' Picnic' or maybe ju...
View full details -
On Sale
JellycatBartholomew Bear All-in-one Outfit
$59.99| /Bartholomew Bear All-in-one Outfit has discovered the ultimate secret to happiness: the all-in-one. Once zipped in, he's officially off duty, slipp...
View full details -
On Sale
JellycatBartholomew Bear Shoulder Bag
$59.99| /When it comes to bags of distinction, the Jellycat crew know a thing or two – and this Bartholomew Bear Bag, inspired by the most popular Jelly of ...
View full details -
On Sale
JC ToysBerenguer Boutique Baby Doll Twins Gift Set
$62.99| /Help children develop their nurturing skills with baby doll caretaking. These two 15-inch baby doll twins are perfectly sized to be cradled in a yo...
View full details -
On Sale
TomyBig Farm Lights and Sounds New Holland 1:16 Scale T7.270 Tractor with Loader
$74.99| /The Big Farm 1:16 New Holland T2.270 Tractor lets your little farmer have plenty of fun while they get the job done. Great for indoor or outdoor pl...
View full details -
On Sale
JellycatBirchly Moose
$59.99| /With its gentle expression and muted, woodland palette, the Birchly Moose Plush brings a cozy, Scandinavian-inspired touch to seasonal displays. Cr...
View full details -
On Sale
HapeBlow-Up Bumper Balls
$52.99| /TWICE THE FUN: Set of 2 inflatable Bumper Balls with animal characters (36in diameter).TWICE THE FUN: Set of 2 inflatable Bumper Balls with animal ...
View full details -
On Sale
TrendTech Wireless ExpressBluetooth FM Radio W LED Speakers Rainbow Bling Boombox
$59.99| /Sparkle and shine with Trend Tech Brands™ Bling Edition Boom box Couture. With Bluetooth capabilities, LED Light up dancing speakers, Phone holder ...
View full details -
On Sale
ToniesBluey Tonies 3 Pack
$59.99| /Bluey and her family have landed, with Bluey, Bingo, and Muffin each packed with their very best adventures. Three figures featuring favorites like...
View full details -
On Sale
Great Pretenders (Creative Education of Canada)Blush Christmas Tree Dress & Headpiece
$57.99| /Celebrate the season in soft, shimmering style with Great Pretender's whimsical Blush Christmas Tree Dress and Headpiece. Designed to dazzle and de...
View full details -
On Sale JC ToysBonbebe 15.5" Weighted Reborn Baby Doll with Real Heartbeat, 16-Piece Gift Set (Pink, African American)
$69.99| /Feel the Love. Hear the Heartbeat. Meet Bonbebé, the beautifully realistic baby doll designed to inspire nurturing play and heartfelt moments....
View full details -
On Sale
JellycatBretti Yeti
$64.99| /Bretti Yeti couldn't be abominable if he tried. He can't spell it, let alone be it. Soft, huggable plush design with long, extra-soft arms built fo...
View full details -
On Sale
BRIOBRIO World - 36092 Dinosaur Erupting Volcano
$67.99| /Rumble, boom, crash! The 36092 Dinosaur Erupting Volcano is about to blow. Create epic prehistoric adventures by integrating this dinosaur-themed p...
View full details -
On Sale
RavensburgerBRIO World - Pull Back Train Set
$69.99| /Pull into imagination station! Train-loving kids and curious early learners start or add to their collection with an heirloom-quality train set fea...
View full details -
On Sale
Bruder ToysBruder Cat Mini Excavator
$54.99| /Realistic, functioning details on this 1:16 scale, Cat Mini Excavator, high quality machine lets it swivel and work just like the real ones! The ex...
View full details -
On Sale
Bruder ToysBruder CAT Mini Excavator with Worker
$69.99| /Beep, beep, beep! Put on your hard hat and enter an imagination-powered world of construction! Kids who love machinery enjoy hours of pretend play ...
View full details -
On Sale
Madame AlexanderBubble Gum Huggable Huggums® Light Skin Tone (12" doll)
$69.99| /This beautiful baby doll wears a soft pink knit top and pants, ready for hugs. 12-inch doll with blue eyes and light brown painted hair, dressed in...
View full details -
On Sale
-
On Sale
-
On Sale
Great Pretenders (Creative Education of Canada)Christmas Tree Dress with Head Piece (sizes 3-4)
$57.99| /Great Pretenders Christmas Tree Dress with Headpiece is the ultimate dress for the Holidays! This fabulous design is so festive it will put everyon...
View full details -
On Sale
LEGO®CITY Drive-Through Car Wash
$74.99| /Working at the car wash, yeah! Build and play brick by brick with a LEGO City Drive-Through Car Wash Set! Car-loving kids will have a blast pushing...
View full details -
On Sale
LEGO®CITY Pizza Delivery Experience
$54.99| /Enjoy hours of food-themed construction and pretend play fun with the LEGO City Pizza Delivery Experience with Vehicles. This toy pizza restaurant,...
View full details -
On Sale
Clementoni USAClemmy Vacuum Cleaner
$54.99| /Includes: 1 sensory vacuum toy with adjustable handle and 6 soft Clemmy building blocks Pretend vacuum "collects" soft blocks for interact...
View full details