Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Milo, our Pug stuffed animal might not be the world’s best problem solver but he makes up for it in irresistible charm! His quizzical expression is...
View full details
This shark is proof-positive that you shouldn't believe everything you see on TV!Sure, some sensationalists in the media will take a whole seven da...
View full details
This super squishy Strawberry Bubble Tea is so cute we can't decide if we want to drink it up or just squeeze it really hard! All 11" of this boba ...
View full details
GUND wants to make playtime a more huggable experience - the My First Purse Playset is full of cute activity toys that are sure to delight baby. Th...
View full details
Babies learn by observing and mirroring - and always want what adults have! Well, now your baby can have their very own 9" plush purse that's safe ...
View full details
Take part in a boisterous dance with Nia, our African Crowned Crane stuffed animal, and discover this exotic bird's dramatic flair! Featuring a rea...
View full details
Noodle is the cozy, comforting friend of our dreams!Her fur is made from luxuriously soft, lightly curled faux fleece in a warm honey-blonde hue, g...
View full details
If you're looking for a special Golden Retriever stuffed animal who is sure to take home the award for "Best in Show," Oakley's got what it takes! ...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
This super-special purrmaid is making a splash with extra flash! The 12 Magical Lights Mermaid Pusheenicorn features only a majestic silver horn an...
View full details
The mythical Caticorn has arrived in a flutter of sparkle and shine! Shimmer’s ultra-soft, pastel rainbow-colored plush is accented by a sparkling ...
View full details
With a mouthful of white, felt teeth and a mischievous expression, Rex the Soft Alligator plush is all whimsy and charm! An Alligator stuffed anima...
View full details
Roz is a delightfully frazzled little explorer!Always bustling with energy, Roz loves rummaging through playful adventures, often arriving just a s...
View full details
Get spotted with Saffron, Douglas' DLux Leopard plush! An armful of exotic fun, this lovable cub is ready for a day of hugs and cuddles. Her beauti...
View full details
Sailor the Pink Turtle Sshlumpie brings cheerful cuddles and gentle comfort to your little one! Her happy expression, velvety-soft textured fabric ...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
Warmies® Plush are fully microwavable to provide hours of soothing warmth and comfort. Warmies are scented with real dried French lavender and perf...
View full details
The Puppet Company Scorch Sockette is a large knitted sock puppet packed full of character. With Bold, bright stripes and a squeaker in its tongue,...
View full details
Imaginations take flight with a blue-eyed, little-winged cinder gray dragon plushie! Sootie Sits at 12" tall and is the perfect size for magical ad...
View full details
