Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Full of puppy like charms, Ace the Yellow Lab stuffed animal finds a way to get out of trouble no matter what mischief he causes! Muddy paw prints ...
View full details
Make a wish!Amuseable Birthday Cake is snuggly-scrumptious, with tussly fur so beautifully baked. This party poppet wears a squashy hat of heavenly...
View full details
Drive-thru realness!The star of any barbecue bash, Amuseable Burger's dressed to impress! From top to bottom, this burger's rocking a brilliant two...
View full details
Amuseables Sports Badminton may look like he’s built for speeding over nets – but don’t be fooled. This shuttlecock is all about flow. Specific...
View full details
All Amuseables Boiled Egg Scientist Outfit’s teachers told her she was destined for greatness. Having swiftly risen through the ranks, she’s curren...
View full details
Amuseables Margaux Madeleine is a stone-skimming prodigy. From calm ponds to the Seine itself, she’s known for her flawless flick – and her effortl...
View full details
Often mistaken for twins, Amuseables Pair of Olives aren’t actually related – but are very much BFFs. Their identical height, similar coloring and...
View full details
Amuseables Planet Mars has a reputation as a bit of a grump. Those colossal eyebrows – which exaggerate his every emotion – haven’t helped. Others ...
View full details
Trusted across the galaxy to deliver urgent messages – and maximum fluffocity – bang on time, fiery courier Amuseables Space Comet has no shortage ...
View full details
Flappy the Elephant is an adorable singing animated plush with two different play modes. Press the left foot to play an interactive game of peek-a-...
View full details
Looking for a unique addition to your fairytale stables? After hours of make believe in fantasy worlds, cuddle up with Anita the Rainbow Unicorn. H...
View full details
Arnold the plush Schnauzer puppy is full of mischief and spunk! Bright, amber colored eyes lend him a sparkle of lifelike charm and reveal Douglas'...
View full details
Asher the Dragon Sshlumpie will spark your baby's imagination with magic and adventure! His cheerful face, soft green plush, and tiny wings make hi...
View full details
A lovable soul, August the Golden Retriever stuffed animal can be counted on whenever you need a gentle friend at your side! Fantastically soft mat...
View full details
This soft baby doll plush is a paw-somely beloved gift for Spring newborns! An innovative spin on soft dolls, this snuggly friend comes swaddled in...
View full details
There's a special place in everyone's hearts for their first teddy bear, so get the new mother or baby in your life a cuddly bear that will stand t...
View full details
There's a special place in everyone's hearts for their first teddy bear, so get the new mother or baby in your life a cuddly bear that will stand t...
View full details
Baby shark, doo doo doo doo doo doo! This soft baby doll plush is a fin-tastic gift for summer newborns. An innovative spin on soft dolls, this snu...
View full details
Larger than life, Bristle the Hedgehog stuffed animal is the go-to pal when you need supersized Hedgehog hugs! His 14" length is stuffed with resil...
View full details
For kids who love reptiles, lizards, and other unique animals, Buddie the Iguana Soft Plush is a cool new addition to their plush collection! Loung...
View full details
Cayenne the Phoenix has risen from the ashes! Cayenne hails from a far away land full of magic, myth and legend and she would love to find a new ho...
View full details
We might be a little obsessed with capybaras at the moment... they're SO COOL! Did you know that these giant rodents: Can stay underwater for up to...
View full details
Meet your new feline friend, a purr-fect plush pal for cat lovers! This adorable Douglas Cherry Pink Cat DLux is ready for cuddle sessions and imag...
View full details
Bring home a spirited Spaniel of your very own with Chip, our Springer Spaniel stuffed animal! Chip features a liver and white coat made with soft,...
View full details
