Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Hold on to your heart because Addie the Caramel Labradoodle plush just might run away with it! With her rounded puppy shape and warm, amber colored...
View full details
Make a wish!Amuseable Birthday Cake is snuggly-scrumptious, with tussly fur so beautifully baked. This party poppet wears a squashy hat of heavenly...
View full details
Amuseables Margaux Madeleine is a stone-skimming prodigy. From calm ponds to the Seine itself, she’s known for her flawless flick – and her effortl...
View full details
Often mistaken for twins, Amuseables Pair of Olives aren’t actually related – but are very much BFFs. Their identical height, similar coloring and...
View full details
Asher the Dragon Sshlumpie will spark your baby's imagination with magic and adventure! His cheerful face, soft green plush, and tiny wings make hi...
View full details
Bashful Black & Cream Puppy is an adorable lap snuggler in soft cream and black fur. This pup is adorable with those floppy black ears and wagg...
View full details
Dog lovers of all ages will want to boop Dove on the nose! With softly weighted paws and airbrushed fur, this 10" sitting plush perfectly captures ...
View full details
This soft pink fawn is a deer-ly beloved gift for autumn newborns! Farrah is a 10" plush forest friend with a whimsical pink coat of ultra cuddly p...
View full details
When it comes to sharks, Great Whites are certainly the most awe inspiring and Fin, our realistic Great White Shark stuffed animal, is as awesome a...
View full details
With his soft, wrinkly body and sad-eyed face, it's easy to fall in love with Hardy, the cuddly Bulldog stuffed animal! Made with the softest plush...
View full details
Polka dots and stripes bring a playful appearance to our lovable Gray Elephant Sshlumpie plush toy. Part stuffed animal, part blankie, this lightwe...
View full details
You'll never be bored when Konner the lively Tri-Color Welsh Corgi stuffed animal comes out to play! Our bouncy DLux plush puppy loves running circ...
View full details
This shark is proof-positive that you shouldn't believe everything you see on TV!Sure, some sensationalists in the media will take a whole seven da...
View full details
Take part in a boisterous dance with Nia, our African Crowned Crane stuffed animal, and discover this exotic bird's dramatic flair! Featuring a rea...
View full details
Noodle is the cozy, comforting friend of our dreams!Her fur is made from luxuriously soft, lightly curled faux fleece in a warm honey-blonde hue, g...
View full details
If you're looking for a special Golden Retriever stuffed animal who is sure to take home the award for "Best in Show," Oakley's got what it takes! ...
View full details
Roz is a delightfully frazzled little explorer!Always bustling with energy, Roz loves rummaging through playful adventures, often arriving just a s...
View full details
Rush is spirited, loyal, and always ready for adventure! His soft reddish-gold plush fur, attentive eyes, and perky ears capture his energetic and ...
View full details
