Find the perfect balance of fun, quality, and value in our $25–$50 Collection at Fantasy Island Toys! This collection features a wide variety of exciting toys, games, plush, crafts, STEM activities, and imaginative playsets that make fantastic gifts for kids of all ages.
Whether you’re shopping for birthdays, holidays, rewards, or everyday surprises, these carefully selected favorites offer hours of entertainment, creativity, and learning — all at a great value.
Why families love our $25–$50 Collection:
• Great gift ideas for every occasion
• High-quality toys at affordable prices
• Fun options for a wide range of ages and interests
• Encourages creativity, learning, and imaginative play
• A perfect mix of bestselling favorites and unique finds
At Fantasy Island Toys, we believe great play should be accessible for every family. Explore our $25–$50 Collection and discover exciting toys kids will love to play with again and again!
Pippa's Princess Carriage has an opening carriage revealing a beautiful dressing room for Pippa. Twist her around to see her magic mirror turn to s...
View full details
Plip! Plop! Ploop! Sorry, we didn't see you there... we can't stop playing with this new open-ended construction toy! It's a collection of 46 silic...
View full details
First steps into the world of music are easy with the Pound and Tap Bench. The colorful balls can be pounded through the holes with a hammer, playi...
View full details
Little ones love to feel like they're helping out, and with this set, they get to actually help out. The spray bottle really sprays, the duster rea...
View full details
The doctor is in! A thermometer, a finger oximeter, an otoscope, a reflex hammer, a stethoscope with real heartbeat sounds, a box of bandages, a sy...
View full details
Fresh from the farmer's market! Kids can carry all the wooden fruits and veggies in the bright green basket like they're shopping for the perfect i...
View full details
Turn schooltime into playtime with this multi-activity set that encourages language and math learning, spatial reasoning, memory skills, imaginativ...
View full details
Wheel them back to get new skills speeding ahead! The “rev up” mechanism inside each of these four cars and trucks makes it easy for babies and tod...
View full details
Move over, Moo Deng... the super soft pygmy hippo is here! A charming and cuddly tribute to one of the animal kingdom's most endearing yet lesser-k...
View full details
Here's the "tea": this rainbow fairy set is a magical pick for pretend play! Serve up memorable pretend play fun at picnics and tea parties with do...
View full details
Interactive steering wheel for sensory development and learning! Activate realistic vehicle sounds and learn colors and numbers by pressing the but...
View full details
With a mouthful of white, felt teeth and a mischievous expression, Rex the Soft Alligator plush is all whimsy and charm! An Alligator stuffed anima...
View full details
Sailor the Pink Turtle Sshlumpie brings cheerful cuddles and gentle comfort to your little one! Her happy expression, velvety-soft textured fabric ...
View full details
Build a castle. Dig for buried treasure. No matter how ambitious the project, the world's most eco-groovy sand play set always leaves a light footp...
View full details
Why does this sturdy vehicle get an A+? It's 100% recycled plastic, dishwasher safe and made in America. A smart choice for imaginative play and gr...
View full details
Satisfy hungry imaginations with Melissa & Doug Water WOW! color-changing play food stir fry! Drop play food into the pot or onto the stovetop ...
View full details
Six pin bowling set includes flat bottomed pins and weighted foam ball.Six pin bowling set includes flat bottomed pins and weighted foam ball. Grea...
View full details
SmartMax My First Animal Train is designed for kids ages 18 months - 5 years, offering an early, safe, and fun introduction to magnetic discovery. ...
View full details
These brightly colored animals from all around the world are a wonderful introduction to magnetic discovery for toddlers. The soft animal fronts an...
View full details
These brightly colored dinosaurs are a wonderful introduction to magnetic discovery for toddlers. The soft dino fronts and backs click easily onto ...
View full details
Start your engines for a wonderful introduction to magnetic discovery for toddlers! Ready for adventures on land and in the sky, 3 happy explorers ...
View full details
